Chapter 10 of 15
Part 3 · Proposals, comparing, signing
Show the whole guide

Part 3 · Proposals, comparing, signing

Before you sign

Before signing, changes are generally easier to make. Take the time to review the contract carefully.

A common homeowner question at this point

Am I about to sign something I don’t understand? And is this deposit they are asking for normal?

Read this first

This chapter explains what California law requires and points you to the official sources, each with the date it was verified. This guide is educational, not legal advice. Your contract is a specific document about your specific project. If something in it worries you, that is a question for a lawyer — and professional legal review may be worth considering on a project of this significance.

The most instructive thing that can happen to you

A homeowner wanted a particular paint. He specified the brand, the primer, the number of coats, the color and the finish. He put all of it in writing — across two separate emails to his contractor.

The contract itself said only: “supply and apply flat latex paint.”

He got flat latex paint. As another homeowner in that discussion put it: “Emails and conversations with workers or the GC don’t change the contract terms.”

The rule this teaches, and it governs the whole chapter

Make sure anything important you were promised appears in the contract or another signed written document.

He did everything a careful person would do. He was specific, he was early, and he wrote it down. It made no difference, because he wrote it in the wrong place. Every promise from every meeting — every “of course we can do that” — has to survive into this document.

This is exactly what the last box on your Chapter 7 question card was for: anything promised verbally that must appear in writing. Get that list out now and check it, line by line, against the contract in front of you.

First: check them again

Lior’s rule

Before signing, re-check license status, and the identity and role of the person selling and signing. Do not rely on the check you did several weeks ago.

Chapter 6 taught you how to run these checks; this is not a re-teach, it is the second running of them. Circumstances change: a license can lapse or be suspended, a bond can be canceled, a workers’ compensation policy can expire, personnel on the license can change. Weeks have passed since you first looked.

Check these four things, today:

Ask AI Mickey about this chapter

Unsure about something in a contract? Ask — it will explain how the pieces work and point you to the official source. It does not give legal advice and will not review your specific contract. It knows the homeowner research and Lior’s experience behind this guide, and the complete 15-chapter guide — and it knows you are on Chapter 10. There is nothing to sign up for and no email required.

0 / 500

AI Mickey does not quote prices or permit timelines, does not give legal advice, and will not tell you which contractor to choose — it will say so plainly and point you to the chapter that covers it. You never need an account or an email to ask, and it is best not to include personal details in a question.

What the law requires the contract to contain

Verified — a written contract is required

A written home improvement contract is required where “the aggregate contract price specified in one or more improvement contracts, including all labor, services, and materials to be furnished by the contractor, exceeds five hundred dollars ($500).”

Note this is a different threshold from the $1,000 license threshold in Chapter 6. The two are easy to collapse into one; they are separate rules answering separate questions.

Source: California Business and Professions Code §7159, leginfo.legislature.ca.gov; CSLB, cslb.ca.gov. Verified August 10, 2026.

California also specifies what such a contract must contain. You are not expected to police this like an inspector — but knowing what belongs there tells you a great deal about whether the document in front of you was prepared properly.

Required elements of a California home improvement contract
Who they are Contractor’s name, business address and license number — and the name and registration number of any home improvement salesperson involved. Check all of it against what you verified above.
The heading The words “Home Improvement” in at least 10-point boldface type. A small formal detail, and its absence tells you the document was not built from the statute.
Your copy A statement, in at least 12-point boldface, that you are entitled to a completely filled-in copy of the contract before work starts. Not a courtesy — a required disclosure. Take the copy.
The money The Contract Price; any Finance Charge stated separately; and the down payment statement. The statute even prescribes the down payment wording — see below.
The work A description of the project and the significant materials and equipment to be used or installed. This is the paint-story line. Vague here means vague forever.
The schedule of payments A schedule of progress payments. Read it against the payment rules below before you agree to it.
The dates An “Approximate Start Date” and an “Approximate Completion Date.” Note the word approximate. These are required to be stated; they are not a guaranteed deadline, and the guide will not pretend otherwise.
What else is part of it A list of documents incorporated by reference. This is how your drawings, specifications and the proposal you chose become part of the contract. If they are not listed, they may not be part of it.
Change orders A required note about extra work and change orders. Quoted in full below — it is Chapter 13’s foundation.
Cancellation Your right to cancel, with a Notice of Cancellation form attached in duplicate. Covered below. Look for the detachable forms physically attached.
Source: California Business and Professions Code §7159 (current text), leginfo.legislature.ca.gov. Verified August 10, 2026. This is a summary of required elements, not the complete statute — read §7159 itself for the full list.
A multi-page printed contract lies open on a table beside a pen and reading glasses, with a person's hand resting on the pages, the text angled away and not legible.
Read the whole thing, including the parts in small type. This is the highest-value reading you will do in the entire project.

The down payment: the rule many homeowners do not expect

Every discussion about deposits argues about what is “standard.” Is 50% down normal? Is a third? People trade opinions about etiquette. In the discussions read for this guide, not one asked the actual question, which is what the law permits.

Verified — the down payment cap

California law: “the downpayment shall not exceed one thousand dollars ($1,000) or 10 percent of the contract amount, whichever amount is less.”

The key words are “whichever amount is less.” Below a $10,000 contract, 10% is the smaller figure and sets the cap. At exactly $10,000 the two figures meet at the same $1,000. Above $10,000, the $1,000 is the smaller figure — so it becomes the binding ceiling, and the lawful maximum down payment is the same $1,000 on a modest kitchen as on a major whole-house remodel.

Source: California Business and Professions Code §7159.5, leginfo.legislature.ca.gov. Verified August 10, 2026.

That is not a negotiating position or a rule of thumb. It is the statute. If someone asks for a large percentage up front on a substantial remodel, the useful response is not outrage — it is a question, because Section 7159.5 contains an exception relevant here, and it is worth knowing about.

Verified — the bond exception

A contractor who furnishes an approved bond covering full performance and payment — a performance and payment bond, a lien and completion bond, or a bond equivalent or joint control arrangement approved by the registrar — is exempt from the down payment and progress payment restrictions, and may accept payment before completion.

So a large up-front request is not automatically unlawful. It does mean there should be a specific, verifiable instrument behind it — and you are entitled to ask which one, and to verify it.

Source: California Business and Professions Code §7159.5, leginfo.legislature.ca.gov. Verified August 10, 2026.
An open checkbook and a pen rest on a kitchen table beside a thick stack of printed pages, photographed at a low angle in soft window light.
What you hand over at the start is capped by law, and the cap is smaller than many homeowners expect.

Progress payments

Verified — the progress payment rule

“the contractor shall neither request nor accept payment that exceeds the value of the work performed or material delivered.”

The statute ties payment to work performed or material delivered. It does not define “delivered” further — how it applies to a specific payment request on your specific project is exactly the kind of question the note at the top of this chapter is for.

Source: California Business and Professions Code §7159.5, leginfo.legislature.ca.gov. Verified August 10, 2026. Subject to the bond exception above.
Lior’s own practice — stated as his choice, not as a standard

Lior personally takes no deposit. His philosophy is mutual trust. He also says plainly: do not pay a large “start work” amount merely because work is beginning, and he prefers progress payments tied to completed milestones — demolition, foundation, framing.

To be clear: this is his own way of working, not a legal requirement and not an expectation of other contractors. Plenty of good contractors take a lawful deposit. The transferable lesson is the structure — payments that follow completed work rather than the calendar.

A payment schedule tied to work

Each payment is triggered by a stage being finished — demolition complete, foundation poured, framing up, and so on.

If work stops, payments stop with it, and what you have paid for is on the ground where you can see it.

A payment schedule tied to dates

Each payment falls due on a date, regardless of what has actually been completed by then.

If work slows, you can find yourself paid well ahead of progress — which is precisely the position homeowners describe as removing all urgency.

One more thing worth asking before you agree the schedule: who is doing the work? Employees or subcontractors, and is workers’ compensation carried where applicable. Chapter 6 explained why that answer matters to you rather than to them.

Newly completed lumber framing inside a residential remodel, with daylight coming through the studs and the floor swept clean.
Payments tied to finished stages like this one are visible and checkable. Payments tied to dates are not.

Your right to cancel

Verified — the cancellation right

The contract must disclose your right to cancel: “You, the buyer, have the right to cancel this contract within three business days” — extended to five business days if the buyer is 65 or older.

The contract must include “a completed form in duplicate, captioned ‘Notice of Cancellation,’ which also shall be attached to the agreement or offer to purchase and be easily detachable.”

Current law also states you may cancel “by emailing, mailing, faxing, or delivering a written notice to the contractor at the contractor’s place of business” — email was added by legislation effective January 1, 2026.

The common misunderstanding: this right is not about signing “at home.” In the ordinary case, the statute’s exception is for a contract negotiated at the contractor’s place of business — negotiate there and this cancellation right does not attach. The law also contains separate special provisions rather than one universal rule: for example, a longer seven-business-day right where the contract repairs damage from a sudden or catastrophic event under a declared state or local emergency, and a separate regime for small service-and-repair contracts. Which provision fits a specific contract is a question about that contract.

Sources: California Business and Professions Code §7159 (current text, as amended effective January 1, 2026) and California Civil Code §§1689.5–1689.7, leginfo.legislature.ca.gov. Verified August 10, 2026.

Two practical notes. Look for the detachable forms physically attached to your copy — if they are not there, ask. And treat this as a safety net rather than a plan: the healthier position, as Chapter 7 said, is never needing it, because you were never rushed.

The change order clause — find it now

Verified — the clause your contract must carry

“Extra Work and Change Orders become part of the contract once the order is prepared in writing and signed by the parties prior to the commencement of work covered by the new change order. The order must describe the scope of the extra work or change, the cost to be added or subtracted from the contract, and the effect the order will have on the schedule of progress payments.”

Source: California Business and Professions Code §7159, leginfo.legislature.ca.gov. Verified August 10, 2026.

Three requirements are worth memorizing, because Chapter 13 turns on them: in writing · signed by both parties · before the work begins.

And one honest gap, which matters as much as the rule: California does not prescribe how a change order must be priced. The statute requires the cost to be stated — not that it be calculated in any particular way. There is no statutory markup limit and no required formula. So how changes will be priced is a commercial question to settle now, in this document, while you still have the leverage of an unsigned contract.

If there is an arbitration clause

Verified — arbitration clauses have their own rules

Where a contract for work on residential property of four or fewer units contains an arbitration provision, “the provision shall be clearly titled ‘ARBITRATION OF DISPUTES.’” The statute prescribes its typography, and requires a notice you initial that begins: “NOTICE: BY INITIALING IN THE SPACE BELOW YOU ARE AGREEING TO HAVE ANY DISPUTE ARISING OUT OF THE MATTERS INCLUDED IN THE ‘ARBITRATION OF DISPUTES’ PROVISION DECIDED BY NEUTRAL ARBITRATION…” — disclosing that you are giving up your right to a court or jury trial, and, unless expressly included, rights to discovery and appeal.

The statute also provides that a non-compliant arbitration provision “may not be enforceable against any person other than the licensee.”

Source: California Business and Professions Code §7191, leginfo.legislature.ca.gov. Verified August 10, 2026.

What you should take from this is not a recommendation. Arbitration is not inherently bad, and this guide will not tell you whether to accept such a clause — that is a legal question about your situation. What you should take is that you are initialing something specific and consequential, that the law requires it to be presented clearly enough for you to notice, and that if you are being asked to initial it quickly, that is the moment to slow down.

Preliminary notices — so one does not frighten you later

Weeks into your project an envelope may arrive from a company you have never heard of, describing your property in formal language. Homeowners understandably read this as a threat. By itself it is not one — here is what it actually is.

Verified — what a preliminary notice is

Subcontractors and suppliers give a preliminary notice to preserve their right to record a mechanics lien if they are not paid. It is given “not later than 20 days after the claimant has first furnished work on the work of improvement,” and goes to the owner, the direct contractor, and the construction lender if there is one. A laborer is not required to give one.

Receiving one can be routine on jobs involving subcontractors and suppliers. It is not a bill, and it is not a claim that anyone has failed to pay.

Source: California Civil Code §§8200 and 8204, leginfo.legislature.ca.gov. Verified August 10, 2026.

Keep every one you receive. Chapter 15 explains why: the names on those notices are exactly the parties whose lien releases matter when you make the final payment.

An unopened business envelope and several official-looking letters sit in a stack on a kitchen counter beside a set of house keys.
A preliminary notice can be routine paperwork. By itself, it does not mean anyone has failed to pay. Keep every notice; the names may matter when you collect lien-release documents at closeout.

Do not rush the signature

Lior’s closing rule for this stage

Read the full contract and the fine print. Understand the payment terms BEFORE signing. Then go over the contract with the contractor — by phone or face to face — and ask about anything that is not clear. Do not rush. You should feel comfortable before committing.

Reviewing these points before signing is easier than trying to resolve unclear terms after work has started.

A thick stack of printed pages left on a kitchen table with a pen lying across it and a mug beside it in early daylight.
If there is no genuine deadline, take the contract away and give yourself time to read it before signing.

Your free pre-signing checklist

Work through this with the contract in front of you. Anything you cannot tick is a question to ask before signing — not after.

My Pre-Signing Checklist

Free, complete and yours. Nothing is saved and nothing is sent anywhere — if you type into it, print or copy it before you close the tab.

The second check

Everything promised is in the document

The money

The formalities

Questions I still need answered before I sign

Anything unticked above belongs here. An unanswered question is a reason to wait, not a reason to hope.

Am I completely comfortable?

Lior’s test, and the last line of the chapter. If the honest answer is no, the answer is not yet.

Keep the signed contract, every attachment and every document listed in it. Chapter 15 is about the file you keep, and it starts with this one.

Still not sure about something? Ask AI Mickey — it knows this guide and where you are in it.

The whole guide, on one page

Before you go on

That is the end of Part 3. The decision is made and the document is understood. Your signed documents are the clearest record of what you agreed. They do not replace rights provided by law.

Part 4 is the build. The next chapter is about what your life is actually going to be like — the lead times that set the schedule, the dust that can travel beyond the work area, and the honest cost in your own time.